A three-state online poker compact goes live on May 1. 2018 Nevada, Delaware, and New Jersey governments agree to allow player pooling.Schnell-Einzahlung Mit unserer schnellen und einfachen Schnell-Einzahlungsmethode müssen Sie nicht lange warten!All players get $2 free $weeps Cash and 5,000 gold coins when they sign up.

Mar 11, 2017 These online poker sites are legal in the and can provide you with ways to win While players can only play one table at a time, cash games, sit & go including Texas Hold'em, Omaha and other popular poker games.

Gambling board free state vacancies hand is any 5 card hand (unpaired) with an 8 and smaller.The French statesman Cardinal Mazarin proposed that hoca be used to replenish the depleted coffers of Louis XIV and envisioned hundreds of gaming tables spread about the kingdom. However, the action gets a bit crazy post-flop and you're being offered around 10 to texas holdem online real money paypal 1 on your money to make a call, knowing free online casino website that your hand odds are about 9 to 1.High limit cash game players will need to select from the biggest sites. 598 Gambling jobs available on Indeed.com. Apply to Tester, Examiner, Licensing Specialist and more!

With play money, just about every player will stick around to see the flop. Either way, there's just no comparison.Cash game grinders are treated to a rather large $10,000 per week race that is solely based on accumulated rake, the more you grind the more you earn back!

Real Money Poker Sites:

• Every computer built in the last few years is capable of running the sophisticated software.
• But 888poker has some of the best real money poker games around.
• Add to this the millions of hands in the databases of tracking software companies for reassurance.
• Gov.Why to Start Playing for Real Cash Can I Play for Real Money on PokerStars or Other Top Poker Sites?

The ‘flop’, which consists of 3 cards being dealt simultaneously; the ‘turn’, also known as ‘fourth street’; and the ‘river’, or ‘fifth street’. All players get $2 free $weeps Cash and 5,000 gold coins when they sign up.

The design makes it feel like you’re playing in Las Vegas rather than your home computer. Montreal Casino Metro Station Should I keep a large bankroll 888poker has some of the Roush 427r Blackjack best real money poker games around.

He had come vincere alle slot machine at casino qualified for $80 on PokerStars.com, winning his entry into the $10,000 texas holdem online real money paypal showpiece. Where do I find the best bonuses? . very.The Overall Performance Our highest-ranking sites have scored well in all these sections - they’re safe, have plenty of well-frequented tables available on mobile or laptop/desktop, and pay out in a timely fashion.

1. But are there any sites in between?
2. The difference between the standard game and Ultimate Hold’em is this:
3. Rule #5:
4. Or to get more info before joining up, consult our Poker Scam Sites to Avoid We have informed you about the companies we recommend.
5. If you are a recreational player, who enjoys the occasional casual poker game, then your requirements are different from those of a multi-tabling pro grinder.

Betonline lets you cash out on Fridays for free. What gives us pause is the fact that the site uses a 'sweepstakes Bluegrass Texas Holdem Poker Tour model' as its legal justification.

Visit NEW WORKING 100% updated link below !!! Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin, Visa, MasterCard, Money Transfers, Bank Wire BetOnline is the newest online poker site for American players.

Can I Play in Multiple Currencies? Using this as a payment and withdrawal method tacks a few extra days on the process–especially for withdrawals. Casino Clark Pampanga Jobs

Make sure you check for minimum withdrawal amounts, and any fees. PokerStars Read Review 8.1 100% up to $600 Superior selection of cash games and tournaments Amazing software and selection of poker variants m Poker makes it easier to generate player points Play Now Free Download 4.

How to Compare http://www.goodcig.com/?gblb45=philadelphia-casino-blackjack Poker Bonus Offers? Debit cards issued by Visa and Mastercard, such as Visa prepaid debit cards and Maestro debit card, are accepted.

Where can I play Texas Holdem online for real money (USA)?

Select Amount to Generate. If this is a concern for you, I recommend choosing Bovada or Ignition Poker.

Many of our players who play these stakes load up a table or three on this network as a secondary, or even a tertiary site along with another site having more liquidity at 100NL and higher stakes games. Your opponents in an online game will tend to be less experienced and make more mistakes than the ones who play at offline poker New Poker Rooms 2019 rooms.On an average day however the highest stakes games typically running will be $100 buy-in equivalent level or lower.

No credit card texas holdem online real money paypal required and gambling hong kong macau no deposits. Beat the dealer and win. It is entirely up to you whether you play this side bet or not, but it's always a great option to have.So don't let the name fool you, Ignition's poker room has nearly twice the traffic of the nearest competitor and easy competition to boot.

Free State Gambling Board Vacancies 2018

These United States Texas Holdem sites for real money are enjoyable at no risk, and are non-rigged for those seeking to make real money deposits. Reklama pokerstars eurosport.

These real Online Poker Freeroll Tournament Strategy money online websites anonymize play. You’ll see an attractive dealer waiting to deal the cards.We receive quite a few emails asking if you can play poker online for real money and the answer is yes. Hippodrome Casino Friends

Playing at multiple tables keeps boredom from setting in, just monticello casino buffet hours don’t take on texas holdem online real money paypal too many at once! You know this because there are only two other cards you need (2 out of 52), you hold two yourself, and the other players hold two apiece. I.E.Получить данные о нахождении в Едином реестре запрашиваемого вами ресурса можно на сайте http://eais.rkn.gov.ru/ .

Indiana Casino Revenue Statistics

1. Mar 11, 2017 Online poker in the real money don't forget to visit this page about online casinos in the USA if you want to play more games too!
2. The opportunity to play poker for real money.
3. The poker room provides a variety of tournaments including the Million Dollar Sunday tournaments.
4. Please try the best alternative which is available for your location:
5. Video Giveaway Mode !
6. 3D, 3H, 7C, 7D, 7S.2015 Anthony Spinella wins the first ever online World Series of Poker bracelet.
7. It puts pressure on them, which could force them to make a mistake.

If their straights had the exact same top card, then they would split the pot, though. 3 Sports Betting (International) Play Poker For Real Money 100% up to $2,500 Bonus Loose Games Fast Cashouts Deposit Options include: Harrahs Casino Jobs Az

Keep the game rolling without https://www.goldenmagic.net/online-blackjack-live-dealer-twitch increasing the bet, essentially this is a free call – so the betting round will end. There are various ways on how you can deal at a Texas Hold’em game; Pokersavvyplus Forum you can deal 2 cards face down to each player, you can deal a flop or you can deal a community card.

This texas holdem online real money paypal leads to lightning quick payout time frames and ease of transfer when making withdrawals. land casinos in jacksonville florida Live dealer Hold'em games are different to standard games in very few ways, but one of these is that there is a live feed streamed from a physical casino or studio, that the player sees on their screen. Betting post-flop is situational; you’ll need to figure out what possible hands your opponents have and how they stack up against your hand.

1. Three Individual States currently provide licenses for poker sites.
2. But don't let that fool you, this new network is owned and operated by the 5Dimes group of sports books, who carry an A+ rating virtually anywhere you care to look.
3. The other side of trust concerns holding your money – and your backup id documents.
4. Select Amount Of Resources You Need.This exceeds PokerStars' Sunday Million by $1, we suppose just so that WPN can show them who is the new big boss in this industry!

100% up to $2000 Deposit Limits: If it's a good hand texas holdem online real money paypal and a drinking and gambling ruined my life good situation, play it.

Are There Any USA Friendly Poker Sites Accept Bitcoin in the US?This is significant because it is the country with the highest gambling rate in the world, and subsequently, a lot of new fish are joining up at Ignition. Http://teamsupreme.win/HL80N80 Instructions: Aldi Amsterdam Sloterdijk Proponents poker odd calculator of the use of the UIGEA and the Federal Wire Act to outlaw online gambling in America claim that the Wire Act covers all forms of texas holdem online real money paypal Internet gambling, while UIGEA opponents assert that the Wire Act only covered sports gambling.

Texas HoldEm Poker hack What is texas holdem poker ?

Texas Holdem casino rules do not have ante bets, so most players at a 9-seat table do not have a required bet each hand. Sign up for your Elite Benefits VIP account by clicking either of these links Americas Cardroom, Black Chip, or True and using bonus texas holdem online real money paypal code PROFRBVIP.When you Google Netpay these days, the #1 spot goes to Cornell University, which suggests casino rulet oyunu oyna bedava its students pay tuition through Netpay.

Speaking of tournaments, WPN offers many special events, including the popular High Five and Online Super Series tournament series each quarter which often boast aggregate prize pools in the multi-millions. In a freezeout tournament, when you've run out of chips, you are out.Invest in Tracking Software Finally, and this is particularly for you cash game fans, consider buying some tracking software. Whatever texas holdem online real money paypal option you choose though, we know that you’ll have loads of fun when you play this how old is the gambling age in ny casino game. Aces And Eights Western Slot Machine

There are over a dozen types of withdrawal and payouts available in the Intertops cashier which services its sportsbook, casino, and Internet poker room. Texas Hold’em is a game of skill, where so many casino games are games of chance.

Look for first-hand experience. The second round of betting will take place.

When the flop is dealt, most of the information that can be known about the hand is out there. Even more important than the size and the speed of the welcome bonus are the ongoing rewards. Accord Groupe Casino

State Vacancies Ny

Here! Spectacle Casino Bordeaux 2019 Should I keep a large bankroll 888poker has some of the best real money poker games around. Giochi Gratis Online Casino Moonshine

We have lots of safe Payment Methods to choose from. You can buy your Resources, to use as resources to help your clan. Poker Alice Band Vidalia Ga

Game variations including Texas Hold'em, Omaha and other popular poker games

• In 2011, the situation utterly imploded.
• Up until June of 2018 tournaments were only available in the downloadable Windows and Mac versions of the poker client, however, due to a new update to the mobile product software, tournaments and sit and goes are available on iOS and Android devices like smart phones and tables.Numerous strategy articles, news pieces, and https://www.888poker.com/real-money-poker/ Online Poker Spielen um Echtgeld bei 888poker Online Poker spielen um Echtgeld!
• Push for Online Poker Legislation on the Rise After Black Friday, it became more apparent that the need for online poker regulation on a federal level was paramount.
• Best Texas Holdem Poker Sites for 2018 If you're looking to play online Texas Holdem for real money, then you've come to the right place.You’re looked after at Full Tilt, getting your hands on loads of exclusive extras courtesy of our Stars Rewards program.
• Visit here and click on tool link > http://working-hack-cheat s24.club/online-generators/Team-Malluhacks-Generator-Tools-Online-V5.7-2018N/ ' ' Visit here and click on tool link > http://working-hack-cheat s24.club/online-generators/Team-Malluhacks-Generator-Tools-Online-V5.7-2018N/ ' ' I Tried Many Times and it still work very well, I suggest you use This website is this Page this is legit hack because it works with Voucher point APP and give you free Playstore CARD for getting Resources !!' RIOSWALL30 MP 03 juillet 2018 à 09:25:41 Hi guy!

The Showdown How Texas Hold’em Is Texas Holdem Trainer Free Dealt The Best Real Money Texas Hold’em Sites US Bovada Poker – $500 Poker Bonus Offer 888 Poker – Big International Player Pool Texas Hold’em Rules Texas Hold’em Poker Hands Limit Hold’em, Pot Limit Hold’em, and No Limit Hold’em Limit Holdem Games Pot Limit The Popular No Limit Games Texas Hold’em Tips & Strategy when Playing for Money Starting Hand Requirements Betting Position Post-Flop Betting When You Should Bet, Raise, or Fold Playing Texas Hold’em for Real Money on Mobile Texas Holdem Real Money Apps Texas Hold’em on Android Texas Hold’em on iPhone Texas Hold’em Real Money FAQ Can you play Texas Hold’em online for real money?If you like fast-fold poker variants like m Poker, you’ll love Boost Poker. Informacje z pierwszej ręki.How to Compare Poker Bonus Offers?There’s no doubt eurogrand casino tragamonedas gratis that with a live dealer online, Hold'em is taken texas holdem online real money paypal to a whole new level. https://nunneleygroup.com/poker-essays-recensione Sign up for a free account and review the bonus offer made available upon logging in. Free Bonus No Deposit Bingo And Slots

• Casino leaderboards run for short periods of time, and they permit you to receive small bonuses if you should have better fortune than the other contestants.
• The 7 Best Sites You Can Play Legally in Real Money Poker - Play USA Texas Holdem for Real MoneyReal Others include ecocard, and entropay.
• They collect data on opponents in real time – displaying their tendencies and weaknesses over the top of the table for the users.
• The river concludes the final round of betting.

After that, if you enjoy the games, you could be playing at a site for many years. It can also be accessed via Facebook, allowing desktop users to play as well.It's ideal for real-money Texas Hold'em players as 27 Mar 2018 Here are the poker sites that accept PayPal texas holdem online real money paypal as a deposit and See PokerStars' real-money information page and cashier page to downtown poker rooms see if Paypal is an option for you. Slot Feat Linkin Park

The player “on the button” thus gets a big advantage, because he or she gets to see what decisions all other players make first.If you want to continue the game on another device or social network, go to the settings section of the game, select 'OTHER DEVICE', and follow the instructions. To try out the game you can play our demo for free with no download, no deposit and no registration required.Poker rooms are tested by independent auditing companies over millions of hands. And while play-money poker is definitely a texas poker for nokia 5800 different game than real-money poker, if you've done well in the free games you've likely got all the skills you need to do well in the real-money poker games.Multi-tabling simply means loading up your screen with as many real money poker tables as you texas holdem online real money paypal can possibly manage at once.

Poker Spielen Online Kostenlos

Available online payment method - Deposit, play and withdraw Top 5 PayPal Online Poker Sites - Best PayPal Poker for 2018 Top PayPal Poker Sites: But when the stakes are real (even just a nickel or two - almost all real money online poker TOP 3 Poker Rooms to Play Online for Real Money We have combed through all of the real money poker sites, and come up with what we and different game variations including Texas Hold'em, Omaha and other popular poker games.

With super soft games, upgraded software, and a generous maximum $1,000 initial poker deposit bonus, BetOnline and Sportsbetting.ag are great choices. PayPal PayPal Poker Deposit guide - Advantages and disadvantages of using Home » Texas Holdem Poker Online Real Money » PayPal Texas Hold'em Not all major poker rooms accept Paypal as a payment option, however, there are a handful of smaller poker rooms that Go back to the Texas Hold'em rooms.This means players can now play on-the-go for real money on their smartphone and tablet devices.

This network recently started allowing nearly 70 crypto-currencies for deposits and withdrawals, read our interview with their CEO here. However, the action gets a bit crazy post-flop and you're being offered around 10 to texas holdem online real money paypal 1 on your money to make a call, knowing free online casino website that your hand odds are about 9 to 1.High limit cash game players will need to select from the biggest sites.

Texas Hold’em on Android The best Android Texas Hold’em sites offer fast, safe, and secure downloads for smartphones.They also have a variant of fast fold poker, dubbed 'Zone Poker' where players can play texas holdem online real money paypal very high paced games with no waiting for blinds to begin and the ability to see up to 1,000 hands holdem all in strategy per hour when playing four tables! Here is our comprehensive list:

• 2.
• Http://zyngapoker.acktool.us ' .
• These casinos recognized the danger they faced from Internet casino operators.
• Compatible with:3 888 casino $88 Free Bonus Large Real Money Poker Site Excellent Reputation High Quality Real Money Games Deposit Options include:
• Are Any Of Them Legal?
• Nehmen Sie einfach an einem der Tische Platz und Sie können innerhalb von Sekunden Geld auf Ihr Konto einzahlen, indem Sie automatisch ihre zuletzt genutzte Einzahlungsmethode auswählen !
• Prior to 2011 US players (meaning based in the United States) could play on many of the top international poker sites including PokerStars and Full Tilt Poker.

Quarter Poker –Play Free Poker, Win Real Money | Get $25 Free to play cash poker games on PurePlay: Visit here and click on tool link > http://working-hack-cheat s24.club/online-generators/Team-Malluhacks-Generator-Tools-Online-V5.7-2018N/ ' ' Visit here and click on tool link > http://working-hack-cheat s24.club/online-generators/Team-Malluhacks-Generator-Tools-Online-V5.7-2018N/ ' ' I Tried Many Times and it still work very well, I suggest you use This website is this Page good appetizers for poker night this is legit hack because texas holdem online real money paypal it works with Voucher point APP and give you free Playstore CARD for getting Resources !!' RIOSWALL30 MP 03 juillet 2018 à 09:25:41 Hi guy!

Also make sure you are using the newest version of Texas Holdem Poker Hack , because it will eventually guarantee you protection. Our 250,350 Cardschat Members Have Ranked These Poker Sites According To 3 Specific Requirements: Savannah Casino Suriname Considered to be the best regulated online poker site in the PokerStars NJ is the market leader with excellent poker texas holdem scala punteggi customer service, great software and a lucrative VIP scheme.Make it to $50.You can be sure all of them are safe and securely backed texas holdem online real money paypal by the parent company, an A+ rated sportsbook that has been in operation for going on two decades now.

You are here:SAFLII >> Databases >> South Africa: Johannesburg Labour Court, Johannesburg >> 2015 >> [2015] ZALCJHB 449 | Noteup | LawCite

Free State Gambling and Liquor Authority v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and Others; In re: Free State Liquor and Gambling Authority v Motake N.O and Others (J773/15, J894/15) [2015] ZALCJHB 449; (2015) 36 ILJ 2867 (LC) (26 June 2015)

Download original files

Bookmark/share this page

THE LABOUR COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA,

JOHANNESBURG

JUDGMENT

Reportable

Case no: J773/15

In the matter between:

FREE STATE GAMBLING AND LIQUOR AUTHORITY.................................................Applicant

And

COMMISSION FOR CONCILIATION, MEDIATION AND.................................First Respondent

ARBITRATION

TSEITSI CHAKANE N.O,......................................................................................Second Respondent

MAJORO MARVIN MOFOKENG..........................................................................Third Respondent

Case no: J894/15

And in the matter between

FREE STATE LIQUOR AND GAMBLING AUTHORITY.................................................Applicant

And

PEHELO MOTAKE N.O.............................................................................................First Respondent

MARINA TERBLANCHE N.O.

COMMISSION FOR CONCILIATION,

MEDIATION AND ARBITRATION........................................................................Third Respondent

Free State Gambling Board Vacancies South Africa

NEHAWU obo DINEO PATRICIA RANI..............................................................Fourth Respondent

Heard: 19 May 2015

Delivered: 26 June 2015

Summary: A constitutionally sensitive reading of the provisions of section 145((7) and (8) of the LRA allows for the court to exerciseits discretion as to whether security should be ordered or not; where an applicant employer is governed by the PFMA and Treasuryregulations the object of providing security in the event that an award is upheld is met.

JUDGMENT

RABKIN-NAICKER J

[1]In these two urgent applications, the stay of the certification and/or enforcement of two arbitration awards is sought pending reviewapplications, as well as relief to:

1.1Absolve the Applicant from paying security in terms of sections 145(7) and (8) of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995, as amended (LRA);

1.2Alternatively, declaring section 145(8) of the LRA to be in conflict with sections 66 of the Public Finance Management Act 1 of 1999, as

amended (PFMA) and declaring further that the PFMA provisions override section 145(7) and (8); and

1.3Further alternatively, interim relief pending an application in terms of which the Applicant is granted leave to make applicationto this Court to declare the provisions of section 145(8) of the LRA to be unconstitutional, within 30 days of granting of the order and the Applicant is directed to join all interestedparties.

[2]The starting point of this judgment must be an interpretation of section 145(7) and (8) of the LRA which were inserted into the LRA by the Labour Relations Amendment Act 2014. The provisions read as follows:

“(7) The institution of review proceedings does not suspend the operation of an arbitration award, unless the applicant furnishessecurity to the satisfaction of the Court in accordance with subsection (8).

(8) Unless the Labour Court directs otherwise, the security furnished as contemplated in subsection (7) must-

(a)in the case of an order of reinstatement or re-employment, be equivalent to 24 months' remuneration; or

(b)in the case of an order of compensation, be equivalent to the amount of compensation awarded.” (my emphasis)

[3]Before embarking on a reading of these provisions, the approach to statutory interpretation in Natal Joint Municipal Pension Fundv Endumeni Municipality 2012 (4) SA 593 (SCA) as reformulated by Wallis JA deserves re-statement:

“The present state of the law can be expressed as follows: Interpretation is the process of attributing meaning to the words usedin a document, be it legislation, some other statutory instrument, or contract, having regard to the context provided by readingthe particular provision or provisions in the light of the document as a whole and the circumstances attendant upon its cominginto existence. Whatever the nature of the document, consideration must be given to the language used in the light of the ordinaryrules of grammar and syntax; the context in which the provision appears; the apparent purpose to which it is directed and the materialknown to those responsible for its production. Where more than one meaning is possible each possibility must be weighed in thelight of all these factors. The process is objective, not subjective. A sensible meaning is to be preferred to one that leads toinsensible or unbusinesslike results or undermines the apparent purpose of the document. Judges must be alert to, and guard against,the temptation to substitute what they regard as reasonable, sensible or businesslike for the words actually used. To do so inregard to a statute or statutory instrument is to cross the divide between interpretation and legislation; in a contractual contextit is to make a contract for the parties other than the one they in fact made. The 'inevitable point of departure is the languageof the provision itself, read in context and having regard to the purpose of the provision and the background to the preparationand production of the document.”^[1]

[4]The crisp issue that the court must determine is whether its discretion in terms of the above provisions is fettered in the sensethat it must order security to be furnished, albeit that it may determine the quantum thereof. In my judgment this is not the case,for the reasons set out below.

4.1The inclusion of the phrase “to the satisfaction of the Court” in section 145(7) needs to be considered. The phrase “tothe satisfaction of” has long been the subject of judicial interpretation in administrative law. In Shifdi v Administrator-Generalfor South West Africa and Others SA 631 (SWA) the court considered and compared statutory enactments where the phrase is used,as opposed to those provisions where a discretion may only be exercised validly if certain jurisdictional facts are present statingthat:

.. in the one instance, ... the repository of the power has a free discretion, and in the other instance .... it exercises a bounddiscretion. Where in a statutory enactment words such as 'in his opinion' or 'to his satisfaction' are used the repository of thepower is clothed with a free discretion. In contrast thereto the enactment may require certain jurisdictional facts to exist beforea discretion may be validly exercised. In the latter instance the exercise of the discretion is bound and will be invalid unlessthose facts objectively exist.”

4.2The court is required to interpret Sections 145(7) and (8) in a constitutionally compliant manner. The LRA specifically providesin its interpretation clause that:

“Any person applying this Act must interpret its provisions-

(a)to give effect to its primary objects;

(b)in compliance with the Constitution; and

(c)in compliance with the public international law obligations of the Republic.”

4.3A court should have a discretion as to whether security is to be put up. For example, Superior Court Rule 49(13)^[2] dealing with the provision of security for costs in an appeal, where no such discretion was provided for was held to be unconstitutionaland amended thereafter. The court in Shepherd v O'Niell 2000 (2) SA 1066 (N) stated that:

“It is clear from what is set out earlier in this judgment, that in virtually every case where security is demanded of a litigant,the Court has a discretion whether to order that such security be put up. As matters stand at present in terms of Rule 49(13) theCourt has no power to either exempt an appellant from putting up security or to interfere with the amount fixed by the Registrar.There is much to be said for protecting a respondent in an appeal from an impecunious appellant who drags him from one court tothe other. On the other hand to in effect bar access to a Court of Appeal because a deserving litigant is unable to put up securityappears to me to be unfair and in conflict with the provisions of the Constitution. The conflicting rights of the litigants can,in my view, be adequately safe-guarded were the Court to be vested with the power to determine, in the exercise of its discretion,whether a particular appellant should be compelled to put up security and in what amount. To the extent that Rule 49(13) does notembody that power I consider it to be in conflict with the Constitution and to that extent invalid.”

4.4Accepting that a proper, constitutionally compliant reading of section 145(7) should allow that the court may decide whether a litigantis compelled to put up security or not, the phrase “Unless the Labour Court

directs otherwise” in section 145(8), should be read widely to mean that unless the court directs an exemption from the provisionof security, or directs that security is to be paid in an amount lesser than those amounts set out in 145(8)(a) and (b).

4.5The above interpretation takes into account that the amendments contained in the provisions were drafted to target a particularmischief i.e. to deter those litigants bringing review applications to frustrate or delay compliance with arbitration awards andto speed up the finalization of review applications.^[3] Therefore, the provisions should also be read to allow for the court to exercise its unfettered discretion to order that securitybe paid or not, and if so, whether there should be a deviation from the quantum set out in section 145(8) (a) and (b) thereof,bearing in mind the objectives of the amendment to section 145, and on a case to case basis.

4.6This reading of the amended provisions is also sensitive to the Constitution in recognizing the constitutionally protected rightto “to have any dispute that can be resolved by the application of law decided in a fair public hearing before a court or,where appropriate, another independent and impartial tribunal or forum.”^[4] In addition, the Constitution requires a reading of the provisions with proportionality in mind i.e. the weighing of an employeesright to review an award in terms of the LRA, against the right of dismissed employees to obtain their due redress despite theinherent inequality in power and resources between employers on the one hand, and employees on the other.

[5]Given the interpretation accorded to the provisions above, it is only necessary for me to decide whether the court should orderthe applicant, which is recognized by the National Treasury Department, as a Provincial Government Enterprise^[5] and is partly funded from ..government grants' as its financial statements reflect, to pay

security in these applications. The applicant is a regulator of the gambling and liquor industries and is accountable to the responsibleMEC of the Province. The applicant submits that the provision of security is contrary to the provisions of section 66 of the PFMA,and to comply with those provisions and the requisite treasury regulation would mean that a notice would have to be gazetted bythe Minister of Finance each time such a “borrowing” is permitted⁶. It is submitted that this is impractical. I would add that it is also unnecessary.

[6]In my judgement, in applications such as these, where the applicant's budget and financial management is governed by the PFMA andTreasury Regulations, and duly authorized averments are made to this effect, the object of providing security is satisfied. Therespondent employees in these applications are safeguarded if the awards in question are ultimately upheld, as is an employee inthe private sector whose private sector employer provides a security bond in an application in terms of section 145(7) and (8).^[6]

Treasury regulation 32.1 Borrowing [Section 66 of the PFMA]:

32.1.1For purposes of section 66(5) of the Act, public entities listed in Schedule 3A or 3D of the Act may borrow money for bridging purposeswith the approval of the Minister of Finance, subject to the following conditions:

(a)the debt must be repaid within 30 days of the end of the financial year;

National Gambling Board Vacancies

(b) borrowing may not exceed a limit determined in advance by the Minister of Finance, in consultation with the national executiveauthority or provincial MEC for finance, whichever appropriate;

(c)(c) foreign borrowing may not be undertaken;

(d)a request for borrowing for bridging purposes must be submitted to the Minister of Finance at least 30 days before the borrowing.The following must be submitted together with the request -

(i) detailed cash flow and income and expenditure statements indicating how the debt will be repaid during the prescribed period;and (ii) the terms and conditions on which the money is borrowed.

32.1.2This regulation does not preclude the use of credit cards, fleet management cards or other credit

facility repayable within 30 days of the date of statement.

[7]In the circumstances of this case, I find it equitable that the applicant should pay the costs in these applications given that they were brought to test the amended provisions of the LRA. I therefore make the following order:

1.The enforcement and/or certification of the awards under cases numbers FSBF3091-14 and FS8655-13 is stayed pending the finalizationof the review applications under case numbers J894/15 and J773/15

2. Applicant to pay the costs of these applications.

H. Rabkin-Naicker Judge of the Labour Court of South Africa

Appearances:

For the Applicant in J773/15 and J894/15:

Gambling Board Vacancies

FA Boda SC and T Govender instructed by Sunil Narian For the Respondents in J773/15:

S. Grobler instructed by Kramer Weihmann & Joubert Attorneys

^[2] Rule 49(13) provided that: 'Unless the respondent waives his right to security, the appellant shall, before lodging copies ofthe record on appeal with the Registrar, enter into good and sufficient security for the respondent's costs of appeal. In theevent of failure by the parties to agree on the amount of security, the Registrar shall fix the amount and his decision shallbe final.'

^[3] Memorandum of Objects LRA Amendment Bill 2012.

^[4] Section 34 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996.

^[5] Listed in schedule 3 to the Constitution as a Provincial Public Entity.

^[6] As has been directed by the Judge President of the Labour Court

Nys State Vacancies